C
Clarity News Hub

What happens if I disagree with Sigurd?

Author

Emily Ross

Published Jan 22, 2026

Agreeing with Sigurd's judgment will improve Sigurd's attitude. Opposing Sigurd's judgment will decrease Sigurd's attitude towards you.

What happens if you don't agree with Sigurd?

You'll have a choice to make regarding Gudrun and Holger, but this won't have any consequences. However, once your first choice is made, Sigurd will arrive. He doesn't particularly like you making decisions when he is the Jarl. He will then give his own judgment and it's up to you to decide if you agree or not.

Should I say Sigurd Judgement is unfair?

Support Sigurd's judgment or judgment is unfair

If you support Sigurd's judgment even though it is not reasonable (30 times the payment), it will lead to the good ending. The ending of the game depends on a lot of these choices in the game. If you make enough good choices, you will get the good ending.

What happens if you betray Sigurd?

Doing three or more of these will lead to Sigurd leaving for Norway but if you have only done one or two, you'll be fine and he'll stay in the settlement with you for good. Plus, he breaks up with Randvi so you're free to be in a relationship with her.

Does it matter if Sigurd goes back to Norway?

If you make 3 Choices against Sigurd (Sigurd Strikes), he will dislike you and leave England to go back to Norway at the end of the game. If you do the opposite and pick the choices in support of Sigurd, he will like you and stay with you in England at the end of the game.

24 related questions found

Does eivor betray Sigurd?

If Eivor feels the same way, this counts as a Sigurd Strike and can negatively affect the ending. If Eivor expresses they 'care for you as a friend' then Eivor will not be betraying Sigurd and is the only honorable choice in this interaction. If you want to romance Randvi at all, wait till the end of the game.

What happens if you punch Sigurd?

Punching both Basim and Sigurd will lower your loyalty with Sigurd and affect the ending. If you choose not to punch Basim or Sigurd then your loyalty will stay the same.

Should you let Sigurd go or tell him to wait?

You must wait until they are separated to avoid impacting your loyalty with Sigurd. In mission Blood from a Stone, you must prevent yourself from punching Basim and Sigurd. In mission A Brewing Storm, give Dag his axe after you defeat him in battle to avoid impacting your loyalty with Sigurd.

Will Sigurd find out about Randvi?

I feel the same way – Eivor professes their feelings to Randvi, and they make love after a little more chatter. Sigurd will eventually find out about this, and that counts as a choice against him. If you make enough of these, it'll affect the ending of the story.

Can I break up with Randvi before Sigurd finds out?

If you break up with Randvi after the first encounter, your actions won't count as a Sigurd Strike and nudge you towards the Good Ending. What's more, if you'd rather not betray Sigurd, all you have to do is wait for the story to progress as the couple will end up separating down the line (40 hours into the story).

How many strikes can you have against Sigurd?

Remember that getting three strikes with Sigurd will cause him to leave England behind, giving players the worst ending. Now that you know how to complete all of Sigurd's strikes and get the best ending, head over to our Assassin's Creed Valhalla guide for even more Viking tips and info.

What are the strikes against Sigurd?

Strike #1: Take the Cargo with you in the prologue. Strike #2: When you get the opportunity, romance Randvi. Strike #3: During the “Blood from a Stone” quest punch Basim and Sigurd when you have an argument. Strike #4: When you beat Dag in a duel during “A Brewing Storm” quest, do not give him his sword back.

What happens if Sigurd stays in Norway?

Selecting 'I understand your anger' results in Sigurd staying in Norway and Eivor becomes the jarl of Ravensthorpe. Selecting 'Your place is here' results in the same outcome - Sigurd remains and Eivor becomes the jarl of Ravensthorpe (A Quiet Homecoming).

Can I romance Randvi and get good ending?

The original guide here warned about getting a bad ending due to romancing Randvi. This is certainly possible, but it is avoidable; players can romance Randvi and good a good ending. They can also steer clear of getting a strike.

How do I keep my Sigurd happy?

In the climax of 'A Brewing Storm' you and Dag finally battle it out. After defeating him, you should 'Give Dag his axe' as a final gesture of respect. Even though he can be quite the annoying bug, doing so will keep Sigurd happy as Dag was, after all, a Viking who fought by your side for most of the campaign.

How does eivor betray Sigurd?

Eivor steals the wealth from Styrbjorn to take with them to England. Eivor starts a relationship with Randvi (Sigurd's wife) before she and Sigurd separate. Eivor loses their cool and ends up punching Basim and Sigurd during an argument in Oxenfordscire. Evior does not give Dag his axe in their last fight.

How can I romance Randvi without betraying Sigurd?

How To Romance Randvi Without Betraying Sigurd. If you'd rather wait until near the end of the story to romance Randvi (thereby giving you the option to romance others such as Petra and Tarben in the meantime), you'll need to wait until Gunnar's wedding during The Forge and the Flame.

Can you romance Randvi after she leaves Sigurd?

The safest choice here is to pick I care for you as a friend. But if you have your heart set on romancing AC Valhalla Randvi, all is not lost. You will be able to hook up with her later on safely, after Sigurd and Randvi break up. This way, you won't upset Sigurd and risk the ending you'll get.

Can you visit Sigurd in Norway?

You'll need to travel to Hordafylke, Norway, and speak to Sigurd to begin this quest. He can be found in the room right next to the Alliance Map room. He'll be sitting on a table — speak to him and a cutscene will begin.

Does eivor become assassin?

Why is Eivor given a hidden blade? Since Eivor received a Hidden Blade without actually becoming an Assassin, they were unaware of the tool's significance.

Is Basim a Loki?

The Twist Goes Deeper: Loki is a Survivor

Assassin's Creed Valhalla's Layla gets to work with Desmond in order to prevent yet another catastrophe, but Loki (as Basim) effectively manages to outlive the other reincarnations and exist until the Modern Day.

Do you fight Sigurd?

Sigurd can't hurt you so there's really nothing to this boss fight. Just wack him a couple times with whatever weapon you'd like. Seriously, he can't hurt you. Let him try — he'll hit you and knock you down, but it won't do any damage.

Why is Sigurd so angry?

After being rescued from Fulke, Sigurd is a changed man that is now highly irritable and seems extremely arrogant on the topic of his bloodline which he claims lets him see things. One of these things is finding out that Randvi cheated on him with Eivor if Eivor decided to sleep with her in the Taken For Granted quest.

Should I punch Sigurd or take a breath?

You should choose to (Take a Breath) as punching Basim will anger both of them and Basim will comment that your lack of control over your emotions is a problem. Choosing the second option here can also affect the ending so punch Basim at your own risk.

Can eivor marry Randvi?

After the wedding ceremony, Randvi will take Eivor to a secluded place. The woman will also confirm that she has divorced her husband. Eivor and Randvi will kiss. Additional information - if you managed to unlock the "good" ending, he will also tell at the wedding that he is happy for Eivor and Randvi.