C
Clarity News Hub

Who is the best choice for Jarl Vili or Trygve?

Author

James Craig

Published Jan 09, 2026

If you want him to be a part of your raiding party, choose Trygve as Jarl. Personally, I chose Vili as Jarl as it seemed to make more sense from a story perspective, but it's up to you, both options end up with Snotinghamscire being an ally.

Who should become Jarl Vili or Trygve?

If you want Trygve to be Jarl, or a choice at all when the time comes, then the answer is to stop him from doing this. However, if you have already decided Vili is to be Jarl then it does not matter what choice you make as Trygve's death would automatically make this a reality.

What happens if you choose Trygve as Jarl?

To put things simply, making Trygve jarl (by selecting "I see Trygve as jarl, and you with me.") will result in Vili joining Eivor's crew, and players will be able to assign him to their raiding parties thereafter.

Should I pick Vili as Jarl?

Personally, I feel like choosing Vili as Jarl is the “best” choice, convincing him to accept the responsibility he's due and secure the long-term future of the county. That's especially true when it's him putting himself on the line for the Raven Clan either way.

Does Vili want to be Jarl?

Allowing Trygve to burn himself to death means that Vili will be the next Jarl and he won't join your crew. Convincing Trygve to live, means that Eivor will have to choose the next Jarl at the atheling.

20 related questions found

Should I let Trygve sacrifice himself?

If you've saved Trygve's life, you actually get to choose the Earldorman. The choice is between him and Villi. On the other hand, if you let Trygve burn, Villi automatically becomes the jarl, and that's that.

What should I remember hemming Jarl by?

Go to the watchtower in Hemthorpe to talk to Vili. The Raven's Clan prepared a special gift for Hemming - a wonderful shield. Eivor wants to additionally decorate the gift and carve a fitting sign on it, which will commemorate the wonderful friend and jarl.

Can you romance Vili?

You can romance Vili when playing either gender.

You can play as a male or female character – this won't block any of the romance options.

Can you sleep with Vili?

You can select the option where you tell him that you also think about what could have happened. After that select the option that you want him. This will trigger the romance with Vili and you will start kissing him. You will then sleep with him.

Who is Tarben AC Valhalla?

Tarben, alias Guthban, was a baker who runs the bakery in Ravensthorpe during the 9th century. He was a former member of a bandit gang but made an oath to himself to never take another life.

Where is Vili?

Find and speak to Vili

Go to the waterfall northwest of Stoneburgh to talk to a friend. You will find Vili in a well-hidden camp in a cave behind a waterfall. You will find out that Vili is not interested in a jarl position, and he believes that his father should accept it.

Does it matter how you remember hemming Jarl?

The first set doesn't matter, but the second set relates to how you will remember Hemming Jarl, and thereby which marking you want etched on his shield. You can choose between Strength, Wisdom, or Determination, with each option's graphic shown in corresponding order on the cave wall.

Who is the hermit to Hemming Jarl?

Erwald Parson (814-) was a Mercian master craftsman and hermit who lived in Nottinghamshire during the late 9th century AD. He was forced into exile after being (in his opinion, wrongly) accused of murder, with Hemming Jarl offering him peaceful exile as an alternative to the crowd's demands to kill or blind him.

Where is Trygve?

Here, we'll break down everything you need to know about On Borrowed Time, including where to find Vili and where to find Trygve. This quest can be found at Ulkerthorpe Fort. It's the teal objective marker on your map.

Where is Vili at Kinder Downfall?

Meet Vili at Kinder Downfall

After the cutscene, you'll need to find and speak with Vili at Kinder Downfall, to the north of Stoneburgh, and east of Hemthorpe. Once you reach the waterfall, climb its northern side to reach Vili without being blocked by ice.

Where is Stigr the amorous?

Stigr the Amorous Flyting Location

Stigr is located near Hemthorpe's longhouse, in the region of Snotinghamscire.

Can you marry Tarben Valhalla?

To romance Tarben in Assassin's Creed Valhalla you will need to first build the Bakery at your settlement. After you've done this you can start doing missions with Tarben. Eventually you will go fishing with him and there will be a romance option.

Can eivor marry Randvi?

After the wedding ceremony, Randvi will take Eivor to a secluded place. The woman will also confirm that she has divorced her husband. Eivor and Randvi will kiss. Additional information - if you managed to unlock the "good" ending, he will also tell at the wedding that he is happy for Eivor and Randvi.

What happens if you break up with Randvi?

If you break up with Randvi after the first encounter, your actions won't count as a Sigurd Strike and nudge you towards the Good Ending. What's more, if you'd rather not betray Sigurd, all you have to do is wait for the story to progress as the couple will end up separating down the line (40 hours into the story).

Does Sigurd find out you slept with Randvi?

You'll be presented with three choices when Randvi admits her feelings to you: I feel the same way: This option sees Eivor and Randvi hook up but Sigurd will find out about this later and—as you can imagine—isn't overjoyed at the news. This is one of the choices in AC Valhalla that will negatively affect the ending.

Can you break up with Petra?

There are various characters in the game you can establish a romantic relationship with. This will face you with a decision to break it to Petra that she's not your number one girl anymore. Whenever you talk to Petra again you will have an option to kiss her, take things even further, but also to break up with her.

Can you still get the good ending if you romance Randvi?

The original guide here warned about getting a bad ending due to romancing Randvi. This is certainly possible, but it is avoidable; players can romance Randvi and good a good ending. They can also steer clear of getting a strike.

Is Randvi with Sigurd?

That said, later on in the main story (SPOILERS AHOY), Sigurd and Randvi in AC Valhalla will break up. If you get with her after that happens, there will be no strike against you. I care for you as a friend – Eivor gently refuses Randvi, but they still remain friends.

How does eivor betray Sigurd?

Eivor steals the wealth from Styrbjorn to take with them to England. Eivor starts a relationship with Randvi (Sigurd's wife) before she and Sigurd separate. Eivor loses their cool and ends up punching Basim and Sigurd during an argument in Oxenfordscire. Evior does not give Dag his axe in their last fight.

How many strikes does Sigurd have?

Remember that getting three strikes with Sigurd will cause him to leave England behind, giving players the worst ending. Now that you know how to complete all of Sigurd's strikes and get the best ending, head over to our Assassin's Creed Valhalla guide for even more Viking tips and info.