Why are there so few left-handed catchers?
Emma Payne
Published Jan 09, 2026
1. Left-handed throws to second base are adversely affected by right-handed hitters. Controlling the running game is important, and the majority of plate appearances come with a right-hander at the plate. So the assumption is that “throwing through the batter” negatively affects the catcher's accuracy.
What's wrong with left-handed catchers?
The most common reason cited is that a left-handed catcher is at a disadvantage in making the throw to third base, especially with a right-handed hitter at the plate.
Has there ever been left-handed catchers?
Contents. The last left-handed catcher to play in the big leagues was Benny Distefano, who caught three games for the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1989. Before Distefano, there had only been a handful: Jack Clements, Dale Long and Mike Squires to name a few.
Why do catchers put their hand behind their back?
A lot of the positioning depends on personal preference and comfort. Wherever it is located, the key is to keep it hidden from foul balls. Many young players are taught to keep the hand behind their back. I'm not a fan of this position because it tends to throw off a catcher's balance too much.
How many lefty catchers are there?
Twenty years ago this Tuesday, Distefano, then a hanging-on major leaguer, served as a left-handed catcher in a major league baseball game. No one has done so since. Like Ladies Night and pitchers named Wilbur, left-handed catchers are effectively extinct — for reasons on which there is bizarrely little consensus.
24 related questions foundWhy do lefties not play shortstop?
You are right on that lefties should not play baseball shortstop or 3rd base. The only positions lefty baseball players should play are pitcher, firstbase and outfield positions. The problem is that so few players can play shortstop and third base there is a supply and demand problem.
Are most 1st baseman left-handed?
Seventy-five years ago, the majority of regular first basemen were left-handers. In 1928, 92 percent of everyday first basemen were, including Lou Gehrig, George Sisler and Bill Terry. Generally, until World War II, nearly two-thirds of regular first baseman were lefties — 64 percent in 1933, 67 percent in 1941.
Why can't left handers play infield?
A catcher and shortstop's mobility is limited by being left-handed. While a right-handed thrower will naturally be in the position to get the ball where it needs to be, a left-handed thrower's awkward range of motion and form adds precious milliseconds to a play in a game where every tiny thing counts.
Are there any lefty shortstops?
If you are asking about left-hand THROWING shortstops, there are only 5. If you are asking about left-hand HITTING shortstops, there is a high number of them, but some of the most famous are: Ozzie Guillen.
Which sport Cannot be played left-handed?
Polo is another right-handed playing sport and the reason for this is because of safety. Playing left handed was banned In order to avoid the likelihood of a head-on collision between players.
Why do I throw right-handed bat left?
The biggest may be that “players who throw right-handed and bat left-handed enjoy an additional biomechanical advantage, with the dominant (throwing) hand being placed further from the hitting end of the bat, providing a longer lever with which to hit the ball,” they said.
What is the easiest position in baseball?
What is the easiest position in baseball? Right field, and the reason is that because 80% of hitters are right-handed, fewer fly balls will go to right field. Most hitters like to pull the ball and pull the ball when they are fooled by offspeed pitches.
Has there ever been a 3 pitch inning?
Completely unofficial and no record books have ever been kept. The following pitchers had no problem with their pitch count, at least for one inning, as they started the inning, threw exactly three pitches and recorded three outs.
Why are lefties better at first base?
Left-handed throwers actually have an advantage playing first base because the only difficult throws that the first baseman usually makes are to third or second base in an attempt to force out a baserunner.
Can a lefty play 2nd base?
In addition, second basemen are usually right-handed; only four left-handed throwing players have ever played second base in Major League Baseball since 1950. In the numbering system used to record defensive plays, the second baseman is assigned the number 4.
Are lefties better at baseball?
Left-Handed Batters
For ages, it's been a well-known fact that lefties do better in baseball. Left-handed hitters are more valuable than their right-handed counterparts at the plate. Lefty pitchers also tend to be more sought after.
What baseball position is best for a lefty?
First base is the only position where having a left-handed player is preferred. The left-handed first baseman's glove is on his right hand and that puts him closer to the fielders when a ball is thrown. It also gives him a better angle when it comes to stretching for the ball and picking up errant throws in the dirt.
What is the rarest feat in baseball?
Unassisted triple plays
The rarest type of triple play, and one of the rarest events of any kind in baseball, is for a single fielder to complete all three outs. There have only been 15 unassisted triple plays in MLB history, making this feat rarer than a perfect game.
Has anyone thrown a 27 pitch game?
Necciai is best remembered for the unique feat of striking out 27 batters in a nine-inning game, which he accomplished in the Class-D Appalachian League on May 13, 1952. He is the only pitcher ever to do so in a nine-inning, professional-league game.
Who threw the slowest pitch in MLB history?
Utility player Brock Holt used a few eephus pitches during a relief appearance for the Texas Rangers on August 7, 2021, one registering the slowest MLB pitch for a called strike since at least 2008 (the pitch-tracking era) at 31.1 miles per hour (50.1 km/h).
Why are there no lefties?
1. Left-handed throws to second base are adversely affected by right-handed hitters. Controlling the running game is important, and the majority of plate appearances come with a right-hander at the plate. So the assumption is that “throwing through the batter” negatively affects the catcher's accuracy.
What is the hardest baseball position?
More often than not, arguments point to shortstop as the hardest position in baseball. Some may point to the catcher, or center fielder, or maybe even pitcher ~ but shortstop almost always ranks high on lists.
What position in baseball has the strongest arm?
Of all outfield positions, the right fielder often has the strongest arm, because they are the farthest from third base.
Why are lefties better hitters?
2. Left handed hitters are one step closer to 1st base than right handed hitters. It's commonly believed that being one step closer to 1st base gives you a better chance of beating out a ground ball in the infield. Every year there are a handful of plays that you are thrown out by a half a step.
Is cross-dominance rare?
Cross-dominance: Very uncommon, about a 1% prevalence. Favoring right foot: 81.0% Favoring right eye: 71.1%